menu
Exclusive Offer Trade free for 90 days + get up to $600 Learn More ×
StockBrokers.com is committed to the highest ethical standards and reviews services independently. Advertiser Disclosure

TD Ameritrade Review

The StockBrokers.com annual review (9 years running) takes six months to complete and produces over 30,000 words of research each year. Here's how we test.

Founded in 1975, TD Ameritrade is a publicly traded online brokerage (symbol “AMTD”) that is home to over $1 trillion in client assets. The brokerage services over 11 million customer accounts and processes over 900,000 trades per day.

In exchange for their higher cost per trade than other brokers – $6.95 for stock trades and $6.95 + $.75 per contract for options trades – TD Ameritrade delivers an exceptional offering across the board. Technology and innovation are central parts of the TD Ameritrade way.

I have been a TD Ameritrade account holder for over 15 years and continue to love the overall experience, especially for traders, and this review will show why.

Review Summary

Rank: 1st (of 16)

The extra cost of trading with TD Ameritrade is worth every cent – the brokerage delivers fantastic platforms, research, mobile apps, education, and customer service. This outstanding all-round experience makes TD Ameritrade our No. 1 overall broker in 2019.

Benefits

  • The desktop platform, thinkorswim, is terrific.
  • Industry-leading customer service.
  • Thanks to technology and artificial intelligence (AI), customers can access TD Ameritrade quote and account functionality everywhere, from Alexa to Facebook and even Twitter.
  • TD Ameritrade runs its own media network, it broadcasts market commentary, and offers interviews and educational segments every trading day.

Considerations

  • Pricier stock and options commissions.

Exclusive Offer:

  • Trade free for 90 days + get up to $600 Learn More

Commissions & Fees

Rank: 14th (of 16)

At TD Ameritrade, you pay for what you get. Consequently, trading is more expensive than most other brokers.

Benefits

  • 313 commission-free ETFs.
  • 4,168 no-transaction fee (NTF) mutual funds.
  • Thanks to an industry price war in 2017, commission rates are much lower than they were two years ago ($9.99 vs. $6.95 today).

Considerations

  • Any commission-free ETF sold within 30 days of purchase is subject to a short-term trading fee of $13.90.

Further Reading

Fees Comparison

FeatureTD AmeritradeE*TRADECharles SchwabFidelity Merrill Edge
Minimum Deposit$0.00$500.00$0.00$0.00$0.00
Stock Trade Fee (per trade)$6.95$6.95$4.95$4.95$6.95
Options Base Fee$6.95$6.95$4.95$4.95$6.95
Options Per Contract Fee$0.75$0.75$0.65$0.65$0.75
Mutual Fund Trade Fee$49.99$19.99$49.95$49.95$19.95
Commission-Free ETFs3132955035000
View all 23 data points

Platforms & Tools

Rank: 1st (of 16)

Once again, for the eighth successive year, TD Ameritrade is number one in terms of platforms and trading tools, thanks to thinkorswim.

Benefits

  • TD Ameritrade's thinkorswim is home to an impressive array of tools. These include company profiling, advanced earnings analysis, plotting FRED data, charting social sentiment, back testing and replaying historical markets tick by tick, or viewing economic and corporate calendars. The brokerage also enables traders to create and conduct real-time stock scans, share charts and workspace layouts, and perform advanced options analysis. The rabbit hole goes as far as any trader's imagination will take them. It’s a dazzling offering of choices that will set your mind spinning – in a good way.
  • Run as a desktop application, thinkorswim is so advanced it is rivaled only by TradeStation. A few clicks of the mouse will have dozens of charts streaming real-time data, and even the pickiest trader will be satisfied with the 400+ technical studies available for each chart (the highest in the industry), not to mention the fact that each study can be customized using thinkscript, thinkorswim’s proprietary coding language.
  • The thinkorswim Earnings Analysis tool is my favorite for planning ahead for earnings releases and assessing each company's results afterwards. The tool plots price action and volatility before and after previous releases. It also pulls data from Wall Street analysts and crowd-sourced ratings from Estimize to plot EPS estimate ranges alongside actual results. The whole experience brings clarity with much less noise. It’s awesome.

Considerations

  • TD Ameritrade used to offer a web-based platform, Trade Architect, which was great for casual investors due to its focus on simplicity. It was finally shut down in 2018 because it was flash-based and unsupported by modern browsers. As of this review’s publication in February 2019, a new platform had not been launched to take its place.

Gallery

Further Reading

Tools Comparison

FeatureTD AmeritradeE*TRADECharles SchwabFidelity Merrill Edge
Web Platform Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Desktop Platform (Windows) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Watch Lists - Total Fields51412510891285
Charting - Drawing Tools2233152222
Charting - Indicators / Studies4111184116695
Option Chains - Total Columns3330412669
Streaming TV Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Paper Trading Yes Yes No No No
View all 59 data points

Research

Rank: 3rd (of 16)

Like its biggest competitors, TD Ameritrade has a substantial research offering. Traders will feel right at home, thanks to the TD Ameritrade Network and unique line-up of tools.

Benefits

  • The TD Ameritrade Network, TD Ameritrade’s live streaming financial network, broadcasts live every day from 8:00 ET to 5:00 ET, and includes an excellent mix of market analysis as well as trader education.
  • TD Ameritrade also provides written daily market commentary and analysis through The Ticker Tape. Content is widespread, covering day-to-day markets as well as general finance, savings, retirement, and trader education. Together with The Ticker Tape, the broker publishes thinkMoney, TD Ameritrade’s quarterly print (and digital) magazine, which focuses entirely on education.
  • TD Ameritrade's website includes a handful of unique tools. For example, the Social Signals tools displays both a real-time streaming feed of algorithmically filtered brand-relevant tweets – which I found much better than seeing a list of recent StockTwits tweets – and a summary chart of the most-tweeted brands.
  • For investors who have multiple holdings that pay dividends, the Income Estimator tool is also very useful. The tool is self-explanatory – just import your portfolio holdings or enter custom positions to view a complete income breakdown. What I like most is the easy-to-use interface and instant takeaways.

Considerations

  • Does the TD Ameritrade Network compete head-to-head with such mainstream networks as CNBC, Fox Business, and Bloomberg? No. But it’s a great foundation, and its quality is beyond doubt; oh, and there isn’t an endless stream of commercials.
  • On the whole, TD Ameritrade does a nice job with its articles. They tend to lean more towards an audience of traders over long-term investors. This is especially true with education. For stock and options trading, TD Ameritrade is great. For long-term investing and retirement-related content, I prefer Fidelity Viewpoints and Schwab Insights.
  • While charting on the website is impressive, there is a noticeable lack of panning flexibility and zooming into the charts themselves. Upgrading to a full HTML 5 charting package such as ChartIQ down the road would resolve this minor drawback.

Gallery

Research Comparison

FeatureTD AmeritradeE*TRADECharles SchwabFidelity Merrill Edge
Research - Stocks Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Stock Research - Reports748123
Research - ETFs Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Research - Mutual Funds Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Research - Pink Sheets / OTCBB Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Research - Fixed Income Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Research - Futures Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Research - Forex Yes No No No No
View all 60 data points

Customer Service

Rank: 1st (of 16)

To score Customer Service, StockBrokers.com partners with customer experience research group Confero to conduct phone tests from locations throughout the United States. For our 2019 Broker Review, 300 customer service tests were conducted over ten weeks.

Results

  • Average Connection Time: <1 minute
  • Average Net Promoter Score: 9.0 / 10
  • Average Professionalism Score: 8.8 / 10
  • Overall Score: 9.01 / 10
  • Ranking: 1 th (16 brokers)
  • View Infographic

Mobile Trading

Rank: 3rd (of 16)

Of all the brokers, TD Ameritrade has the most tech-focused mobile offering. With AI central to its long-term strategy, TD Ameritrade is literally everywhere. Looking at apps specifically, Mobile Trader is my top pick for traders in 2019.

Benefits

  • With mobile, TD Ameritrade took a different approach by offering not one, but two smartphone apps: TD Ameritrade Mobile and TD Ameritrade Mobile Trader. TD Ameritrade Mobile is designed for casual investors, while TD Ameritrade Mobile Trader is designed for the feature-hungry active trader.
  • TD Ameritrade was one of the first brokers to offer an Alexa Skill, and in August 2017, it became the first broker to integrate with Facebook Messenger, embracing the future of artificial intelligence (AI) with its own chatbot. The latest addition in 2018 was Apple Business Chat, which I am using more and more frequently to grab quick stock quotes. Bottom line, if you appreciate technology and AI, you will enjoy TD Ameritrade.
  • Looking at specific functionality, TD Ameritrade Mobile Trader is “where the magic happens.” The best way to think of Mobile Trader is to think of the thinkorswim platform in app form. The combination of effective design and advanced trader functionality is a winner.
  • On the other end, TD Ameritrade Mobile can be considered a natural extension of the TD Ameritrade website. Functionality is still comprehensive, but not as deep as Mobile Trader. Because of its focus on investors over traders, TD Ameritrade Mobile provides a superior research and education experience. For example, quotes include six third-party ratings and PDF reports from the website, whereas Mobile Trader doesn’t.

Considerations

  • Watch lists created on the website only sync with TD Ameritrade Mobile, while watch lists on thinkorswim only sync with Mobile Trader.
  • TD Ameritrade Mobile lacks a customizable dashboard, which I feel opens the door to much more relevant account personalization and insights, especially for investors. In comparison, this is an area where Fidelity's mobile app shines.

Gallery

Further Reading:

Mobile Apps Comparison

FeatureTD AmeritradeE*TRADECharles SchwabFidelity Merrill Edge
iPhone App Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Android App Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Apple Watch App Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Watch List Syncing Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Stock Alerts - Basic Fields Yes Yes No Yes Yes
Charting - After Hours Yes Yes No Yes Yes
View all 52 data points

Offering of Investments

Rank: 2nd (of 16)

TD Ameritrade provides everything one might expect of a full-service brokerage.

Benefits

  • Full spectrum of investment services provided, everything from stock trading to retirement guidance.
  • Futures and forex trading are also offered.

Considerations

  • When it comes to international trading, TD Ameritrade customers can only trade US and Canadian-listed securities.

Further Reading

Offering Comparison

FeatureTD AmeritradeE*TRADECharles SchwabFidelity Merrill Edge
Stock Trading Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
OTCBB / Pink Sheets Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Options Trading Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Complex Options Max Legs44442
Futures Trading Yes Yes Yes No No
Forex Trading Yes No No No No
Mutual Funds (No Load)51856266584640312471
Advisor Services Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
View all 40 data points

Education

Rank: 1st (of 16)

Excellent education makes TD Ameritrade an easy winner for beginners.

Benefits

  • Content is organized into courses with quizzes, and the website gamifies learning by awarding points alongside badges to encourage further education.
  • Over 200 videos are available, including endless articles through thinkMoney magazine and The Ticker Tape.
  • Hundreds of optional webinars and educational sessions are provided every month.
  • In our testing, TD Ameritrade was the only broker to score a perfect 100%.

Considerations

  • None.

Gallery

Further Reading:

Education Comparison

FeatureTD AmeritradeE*TRADECharles SchwabFidelity Merrill Edge
Has Education - Stocks Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Has Education - ETFs Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Has Education - Options Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Has Education - Mutual Funds Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Has Education - Fixed Income Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Has Education - Retirement Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
View all 19 data points

Banking

Rank: 6th (of 16)

Customers who bank with TD Ameritrade are not protected by FDIC insurance; however, the broker does provide basic services to customers.

Benefits

  • 364 retail service centers.
  • Like its closest competitors, TD Ameritrade also provides mobile check deposit, online bill pay, and ATM fee reimbursement.

Considerations

  • No savings accounts offered.
  • Unlike competitors Merrill Edge, Charles Schwab, and E*TRADE, TD Ameritrade is not a registered member of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), which insures bank deposits up to $250,000.
  • Using multiple banking products in conjunction with brokerage yields no bonus rewards, which is where Bank of America Merrill Edge thrives.

Further Reading

Banking Comparison

FeatureTD AmeritradeE*TRADECharles SchwabFidelity Merrill Edge
Member FDIC No Yes Yes No Yes
Checking Accounts Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Savings Accounts No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Credit Cards Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Mortgage Loans No No Yes No Yes
Retail Locations364303571974400
View all 12 data points

Final Thoughts

Rank: 1st (of 16)

TD Ameritrade is a technology-focused company that just gets it. They understand their customers and the value of a high-quality user experience, and they know what it takes to stay ahead of the competition.

Any investor or trader, new or seasoned, will find TD Ameritrade a great fit for their needs. The main gripe with the broker is cost, but what you pay for is what you get, and the quality delivered by TD Ameritrade is undoubtedly worth the extra few dollars per trade.

In 2019, TD Ameritrade is on top and finished first overall.

For our 2019 Review we assessed, rated, and ranked 16 different online brokers over a period of six months. How we test.


Blain Reinkensmeyer

About the author: Blain Reinkensmeyer As Head of Research at StockBrokers.com, Blain Reinkensmeyer has 18 years of trading experience with over 1,000 trades placed during that time. Referenced as a leading expert on the US online brokerage industry, Blain has been quoted in The New York Times, Forbes, and the Chicago Tribune, among others.

All pricing data was obtained from a published web site as of 02/18/2019 and is believed to be accurate, but is not guaranteed. For stock trade rates, advertised pricing is for a standard order size of 500 shares of stock priced at $30 per share. For options orders, an options regulatory fee per contract may apply.

TD Ameritrade, Inc. and StockBrokers.com are separate, unaffiliated companies and are not responsible for each other’s services and products. View terms.

arrow_drop_upBack to top